Mission Briefing: Ideas that shape world mission outreach today

Comity or collaboration?

Two approaches to defusing a sense of competition on the mission field

In the 1800s, several Protestant denominations entered into comity agreements with each other regarding global missionary efforts. These agreements called for each denomination to confine its ministry to specified areas in each country. In return, that denomination received exclusive rights to do ministry in those assigned areas. This included a provision that all churches in each geographical domain would belong to the denomination assigned to that area.

Comity agreements were supposed to eliminate unnecessary duplication, reduce confusion among unbelievers, and diminish "competition" among churches. However laudable those goals may have been, the system had serious flaws, including:

Fostering an "empire mentality" among missionaries regarding the geographic area and people which were their denomination's exclusive ministry domain.

Geographically separating denominations reduced "cross-pollination" and the helpful interaction with peers of other Christian traditions. Too often, missionaries wound up simply replicating things from their home country.

Eliminating choice for believers in terms of theological perspectives and worship styles due to the "mono-denominational" aspect of each geographical area. Thus, when a Baptist family moved from one city to another, they likely would have had to become, for example, Episcopalian.

For these and other reasons, the comity system fell short of its lofty expectations. By the middle of the twentieth century, it had been discarded.

Today, there's something better going on than comity agreements. It's called collaboration. To be sure, comity could be seen as a type of collaboration. However, it was basically an agreement saying, "I'll stay out of your territory if you'll stay out of mine."

Today, missionaries around the world collaborate on things ranging from dealing with government officials to compassionate ministry efforts. Collaboration doesn't involve obliterating denominational distinctive. It simply means walking alongside each other and interacting in ways supportive of the core values of each group.

One example of what goes on today in terms of collaboration would be a well drilling project in Haiti. We Nazarenes got a grant from a Canadian provincial government to drill village water wells. We provided the well locations, usually the corner of a church property. We didn't have well-drilling equipment, but the Mennonites did. The Mennonites didn't have the needed hand pumps, but World Vision did.

Another example of good collaboration would be Nazarene missionary Bill Dawson organizing a consortium of medical ministries to import pharmaceutical supplies into Haiti. By buying in large quantities, those dozen or so groups greatly reduced the cost of medical supplies for everyone.

A Scripture distribution ministry's 25th anniversary provides another example. That organization solicited ideas on how to celebrate their anniversary. Nazarenes in Haiti proposed distributing 25,000 Creole New Testaments which believers could "earn" in a variety of ways. That proposal was accepted and, through this collaborative effort, New Testaments wound up in the hands of lots of believers who had never owned a copy of Scripture!

Such scenarios in which missionaries from different organizations collaborate together remind me of a floral bouquet in which different kinds of flowers each have something unique to contribute to the whole in terms of color, texture, fragrance and so on. I believe God is pleased with our "collaboration bouquet."

    -- Howard Culbertson

This 500-word mini-essay on a key issue in world missions outreach is an article in the "Mission briefing" series published in Engage, a monthly online magazine produced by the Church of the Nazarene.

" Oh, how wonderful, how pleasing it is when God's people all come together as one!" -- Psalm 133:1, Easy-to-Read Version


Bible passages relevant to Great Commission fulfillment    Doing missions well: Biographical sketches     Fiery sayings to inspire global evangelism    World missions slogans    Mini-essays on missionary Bible verses