General case study guidelines to aid your reflection and discussion.
Venkayya felt the burning forehead of his young daughter. He had prayed fervently all afternoon, and still the fever mounted. The red spots on the child's face and body left no doubt that she had come down with smallpox.
• Would she die like so many other children in the village?
• Did God really care?
• Might giving one rupee to the goddess Misamma actually spare her life?
• Should he listen to his younger brothers and give in to the village pressure?
• What did the Bible mean when it said that a Christian should have no other gods but God?
Venkayya's dilemma began when a plague of smallpox came to Muchintala, a small village in south India. The village elders called the government doctor. He distributed medicines and gave shots. Sadly, these seemed to have little effect on the spreading disease. After a number of children had died, the elders called in the village diviner to determine the reason for the plague.
The diviner announced that Misamma, the goddess of smallpox who lived in a rock under a tree outside the village, was angry with the village. The diviner reminded the village that five years before, they had offered Misamma only two goats instead of the usual water buffalo at her festival. Since then, no feast had been held. Since Misamma expected a sacrifice every three or four years, the diviner said she was now angry with the village.
When the elders heard this, they began to arrange for a water buffalo sacrifice. Messengers went to every house in the village to gather donations to purchase the animal. The elders knew that, to satisfy the goddess, every household needed to contribute something.
When a messenger came to the house where Venkayya and his two younger brothers lived, Venkayya told the man that he and his brothers had become Christians three years earlier. Because of that, they could not make a contribution for the sacrifice. It would be against their religious beliefs.
The messenger reported this to the high-caste elders who became very angry. How could anyone in the village, especially an "untouchable" such as Venkayya, disobey their orders? Summoning Venkayya, they demanded an explanation. He told them that he and his brothers had become Christians, and that Christians worshiped no gods but the God of the Bible. Their God, Yahweh, would take care of them, he said.
The elders responded that they did not object if Venkayya and his family worshiped the Christian God. Everyone had a right to worship his or her own god (ishta devata). But Misamma was something different. She was not a god like Rama, Allah, or the Christian God, all of whom live in the heavens.
Misamma was an earthly spirit who lived near their village. If the village did not keep her satisfied, she would continue to plague the children. Everyone in the village had to contribute something or Misamma would be displeased. Besides, was just giving her something to eat really worship?
"Even the Muslims," they said, "who worship only one god, gave money to buy the water buffalo so that their children would not die."
Venkayya responded that a Christian could not offer a sacrifice, even to local spirits. The elders grew more angry. It was all right, they said, if he killed his own children by refusing to make the sacrifice, but he was to blame if other children in the village died. Moreover, he was disobeying the village elders, and that was an unforgivable offense.
To show their authority and pressure him to change his mind, the elders placed Venkayya, his brothers, and their families under a village ban. No one in the village could talk to them, sell them goods, or marry their children. If they did, they too would come under the ban.
The next week was difficult for the new Christians. They had to walk to the next village to buy food. Because they were forbidden to go to their caste well, the women had to fetch water from the stream a half mile outside of town.
When more children died, the elders summoned Venkayya. They told him that if he did not contribute a rupee for the offering, they would bar him from working his fields. Again, Venkayya held fast to his previously stated convictions.
The following week was almost unbearable. The young men of the village prevented Venkayya and his brothers from irrigating their small rice fields. Under the hot sun, the paddy began to wilt. If something was not done soon, there would be no harvest and nothing to live on next year.
Finally, Rangayya and Pullayya, Venkayya's younger brothers, came to him and said, "We must give in to the pressures of the elders or we will all die. God will understand if we give them a rupee. We will tell him we did not give it as an offering to the spirit, but as a tax demanded by the village elders. Besides, Misamma is not a goddess living in the heavens. She is only a local godling living in a rock. Offering her a sacrifice is not worship. It is only food to placate her anger. It is like giving something to a belligerent official to keep the peace."
Four days later, Venkayya's own little daughter came down with the dread disease. Venkayya began to doubt his own judgment. So, he went to see the missionary who lived forty miles away. The missionary prayed for Venkayya's daughter and exhorted him to stand firm in his refusal to contribute to the sacrifice.
Today, Venkayya and the family had prayed all afternoon, but God seemed so far away. The medicine the doctor gave him made little difference in the girl's rising fever. To himself Venkayya thought: Was I wrong in refusing to contribute even one rupee to the elders? Clearly, local spirits like Misamma were not gods like the God of the Bible. Was it wrong, therefore, to feed them to keep them happy? They were little different from the officials who made life hard for everyone in the village and needed to be placated with gifts. Maybe the missionary was wrong. He really did not understand the village or the local spirits. Can't I pray for God's healing of my child and, at the same time, give a rupee for the sacrifice?
As night came, Venkayya looked at his wife as she pleaded with God for the life of her child. Would God heal the little girl? And if God did not, what would he say when villagers scoffed at his God? Maybe his brothers were right. Maybe he should go to the village headman and give him one rupee to help buy a water buffalo for Misamma. Then, who knows, his daughter might live. And even if she did not, he would not be blamed for the deaths of other children. Then he could work the fields and his family live in the village in peace.
Finally, he decided to . . .
This case study appeared in its original form in Case Studies in Missions, edited by Paul and Frances Hiebert, Baker Book House, 1987. Edited and used by permission. This case study may be reproduced only upon payment of a 35-cent royalty per copy to Baker Book House, P.O. Box 6787, Grand Rapids, MI 49516 USA
Howard Culbertson, 5901 NW 81st, Oklahoma
City, OK 73132 | Phone: 405-740-4149 - Fax:
Updated: January 29, 2019